Login

close

Login

If you are a registered HEi-know user, please log in to continue.


Unregistered Visitors

You must be a registered HEi-know user to access Briefing Reports, stories and other information and services. Please click on the link below to find out more about HEi-know.

Find out more
Emerging HE policies highlight new political landscape

Interventionism is suddenly all the rage with the Westminster Conservative government, and higher education is feeling the impact as new policies and legislation are brought to bear on the sector, writes Johnny Rich, Chief Executive of Push and of the Engineering Professors’ Council.

Rethinking universities from the outside in

Mike Boxall, an independent researcher and consultant on higher education policies and strategies, and a senior adviser to PA Consulting, considers the emerging post-COVID world and its implications for the future of universities. His blog is based on a paper published recently by PA Consulting, and co-authored with its HE lead, Ian Matthias.

Is the government missing the real 'levelling up' value of HE?

The Westminster government should wake up to the full potential of higher education to help it meet its ‘levelling up’ goals, argues Professor Martin Jones, Deputy Vice-Chancellor at Staffordshire University.

After a week of 'people power' it is time to listen to students

Jonathan Baldwin, managing director of higher education at Jisc, reflects on a week that’s felt the force of people power – and says it’s time for university leaders to respond to students’ calls for change.

HEi-think: Royal Society-British Academy project will address educational research crisis

The Royal Society and British Academy have launched a joint project to examine how best to harness new and up-to-date research methodologies, using the latest technologies, big data and interdisciplinary approaches, to improve educational outcomes for young people in the UK and internationally. Professor John Leach, Pro Vice-Chancellor at Sheffield Hallam University, who is a member of the working group for the project, explains why it is needed.

 

The Royal Society and British Academy have launched a joint project on educational research, which comes with a call for evidence

The United Kingdom has a strong track record of producing excellent educational research, and using research to inform both policy and practice.  In 2014, 66% of the work in education submitted to the Research Excellence Framework (REF) was rated as world-leading or internationally excellent, which is almost exactly the same proportion as for the social sciences as a whole.  Furthermore, more than three quarters of the score for impact was rated as world-leading or internationally excellent.  The critiques on the quality and relevance of educational research made in the 1990s by Hillage and others do not appear salient today.

However, educational research capacity is under threat.  There was a 15% reduction in the number of researchers submitted to the REF in 2014 when compared to the Research Assessment Exercise in 2008.  Anecdotal evidence suggests that fewer early career educational researchers are graduating with PhDs and securing academic positions in UK universities: the age profile of UK educational researchers is rising and there is no obvious mechanism for securing succession.  The information revolution is also making an impact on the ways both education and educational research is conducted.  Massive amounts of data about education are now available for analysis, and there are new mechanisms for producing and disseminating knowledge.

It is against this background that the Royal Society and British Academy project is being launched.  Although restricted to science and mathematics education, these issues were identified in the Royal Society's 2014 report  Vision for science and mathematics education.  The scope of the current project was broadened to address all aspects of educational research, in recognition that education operates as a system, and that not all educational research is conducted by people who work in universities.  Educational research is an international endeavour, and the scope of the project will include gathering evidence from other nations about the generation and use of research knowledge to inform educational policy and practice.

The irony of writing a post about enhancing evidence-informed policy-making in education this week has not escaped me.  Our government has just put out for consultation a Green Paper which, if implemented, will see permission given for (English) schools to reject pupils because they are not sufficiently academically able, and for funding currently spent by universities on widening participation to be diverted into university sponsorship of schools. 

My colleague Professor Chris Husbands, Vice-Chancellor of Sheffield Hallam University,  recently blogged  about grammar schools, describing the evidence suggesting that they will do the opposite of what the green paper says (i.e. grammar schools have the option to reject pupils, rather than giving parents the choice to select schools for their children; grammar schools don't address the needs of modern economies for large numbers of highly-skilled workers; it isn't possible to predict reliably attainment at 16 or 18 in tests administered at 11).  Evidence about the outcomes of university sponsorship of schools is no more convincing.  I am aware of excellent schools which have university sponsors (including the schools sponsored by Sheffield Hallam University) - but a quick Google search will show that there are examples of failure as well as success.  What is the evidence that university sponsorship of schools leads to better outcomes than other governance arrangements?

Evidence-informed education policy-making and practice needs support from those of us in the HE system.  The RS and BA are championing the cause through this project.  Please respond to the call for evidence.

 

dizanna / 123RF
Back