If you are a registered HEi-know user, please log in to continue.

Unregistered Visitors

You must be a registered HEi-know user to access Briefing Reports, stories and other information and services. Please click on the link below to find out more about HEi-know.

Find out more
Is the admissions system ready for reform?

With calls for a post-qualification admissions system, greater transparency around unconditional university offers, and the need for a more ambitious contextual admissions strategy – is the current admissions process fit for purpose or is it ready for a refresh? June Hughes, University of Derby Secretary and Registrar, discusses the complexity of the university system.

The TEF may not be perfect -- but it's still worth going for gold

As the latest Teaching Excellence and Student Outcomes Framework (TEF) results are published, Sue Reece, Pro Vice-Chancellor (Student Experience) at Staffordshire University, says the efforts her institution made to move up from a Silver to a Gold award were worth it, despite flaws in the TEF methodology.

Study finds progress on tackling hate crime and sexual harassment on campus

Universities awarded funding as part of a large-scale programme to tackle hate crime and sexual harassment on campus have made good progress, an evaluation of the scheme has concluded.

Hinds urges OfS to take “ambitious” measures to protect HE standards

Education Secretary Damian Hinds has urged the Office for Students to adopt “ambitious” new measures “in order to tackle risks to the world class quality of higher education” in the UK.

REF-style teaching assessment and more women university managers needed, says minister

Plans for a framework to assess teaching quality, a concerted drive for more women in senior posts, and reassurance over the review of research councils, were among key messages for vice-chancellors from universities minister Greg Clark in a speech at the Higher Education Funding Council for England’s annual conference.

More focus is needed on ways to make differences in teaching quality more discernible to actual and prospective students, he told delegates at the conference in London. He said he envisaged measures to assess teaching that would support a similar competition on quality to that of the Research Excellence Framework.

“I welcome the work HEFCE is doing to refine and test new indicators of teaching quality and learning gain and, indeed, innovation in teaching,” he said.

The Minister assured vice chancellors and other senior university managers at the event that institutions would have significant input into the review of research councils by Sir Paul Nurse and be well represented on the review panel.

He dismissed fears that the review threatened the present system for funding research, promising that “the dual funding system – supporting research projects and institutions – works well and is here to stay”, and adding:  “Excellence, determined by peer review and funded wherever it is found, is the touchstone of that system.”

The review will work with the research councils and build on their firm foundations while looking at the “opportunities for agility and for further collaboration in the 10 years ahead,” he said.

The minister rejected calls for the £9,000 tuition fee to be raised with inflation, saying there was instead an opportunity for institutions to be a bit clearer about how the fee was used, giving greater clarity to students.

While praising higher education for its significant contribution to the economy and its world class reputation for research, the minister criticised the lack of diversity in its leadership.  At least half of the top students in universities were women and recruitment increasingly reflected society, but women were still absent from long lists for senior university appointments.  It was “not good enough” to say women were absent because they had not applied.

“In the commercial world if you are recruiting to a position you value highly you want to go out and find the best people, to tap them on the shoulder sometimes quite literally, and say do apply, you will be brilliant at it - not just wait and hope they will see it. Academic networks are among the most developed in the country - people know people and they need to be activated. I know there is an appetite to do that but the pace could be increased a little,” he said.

Further emphasising the point, he added: “If I am presented with a long list for appointments from which women are absent I send it back – not because I believe in quotas or reserved positions, but because I suspect that the recruitment process has failed to do enough to find the full range of talent and leadership that I expect to be able to appoint from.”

In comments clearly aimed at Labour’s proposals to lower tuition fees, he said it would be “a profound misjudgement” for any future government to throw away a system that was delivering.

“It would bring on the chaos of permanent and fundamental uncertainty that would result from the need to go cap-in-hand to the Treasury each year for funding attached to a tangle of strings,” he said. The idea of a graduate tax was more of a graduate penalty and “a klaxon warning that if you’re talented and expect to earn well then don’t risk getting a higher education”.

Jeremy Pocklington, the Director of the Enterprise and Growth Unit and the Treasury, told the conference successive ministers had recognised the importance of higher education to the economy based on macro-economic evidence.  But difficult decisions remained to be made in future about where the marginal pound would be invested.

“To help the sector make its case it is important that we all continue to build on that evidence base,” he said. “There are areas where we need to continue to engage with you to understand the value of higher education to the individual and to the country.”

Jonathan Dimson from McKinsey & Company said the world’s economies were heading east. “Where you look at where the middle class consumers – and your students - will be coming from it is predicted there will be 2.2 billion globally by 2030 and 1.7 billion of them will be coming out of Asia Pacific.”

Speaker Diane Coyle, professor of economics at the University of Manchester, said people tended to focus on and over-hype the short term impact of technology and under-play the longer term changes it would make to the world. Technology should be complementary to what institutions do and not replace it. She advised: “Think about what you are giving student face to face that they can’t get from computers.”






Greg Clark