Login

close

Login

If you are a registered HEi-know user, please log in to continue.


Unregistered Visitors

You must be a registered HEi-know user to access Briefing Reports, stories and other information and services. Please click on the link below to find out more about HEi-know.

Find out more
The TEF may not be perfect -- but it's still worth going for gold

As the latest Teaching Excellence and Student Outcomes Framework (TEF) results are published, Sue Reece, Pro Vice-Chancellor (Student Experience) at Staffordshire University, says the efforts her institution made to move up from a Silver to a Gold award were worth it, despite flaws in the TEF methodology.

Study finds progress on tackling hate crime and sexual harassment on campus

Universities awarded funding as part of a large-scale programme to tackle hate crime and sexual harassment on campus have made good progress, an evaluation of the scheme has concluded.

Hinds urges OfS to take “ambitious” measures to protect HE standards

Education Secretary Damian Hinds has urged the Office for Students to adopt “ambitious” new measures “in order to tackle risks to the world class quality of higher education” in the UK.

"Open border" universities perform best in new U-Multirank rankings

The most internationally engaged "open border" universities perform best in the quality of their education, research impact, and knowledge transfer, according to U-Multirank, which has published its latest set of global rankings.

Augar proposals must not mean supporting FE at the expense of HE

The Augar review panel was right to highlight under-funding of further education, but addressing this should not mean cuts in the higher education budget, argues Dr Joe Marshall, Chief Executive Officer of the National Centre for Universities and Business (NCUB).

News headlines finally reflect the concerns of universities

This week’s news for once truly mirrors the issues focusing minds in HE, finds Rachel Hewitt, Director of Policy and Advocacy at the Higher Education Policy Institute.

 

We often say that the media coverage of the higher education sector does not reflect what is actually going on within UK universities. However, aside from the seemingly unavoidable free speech stories, this week has been the exception to that rule. The headlines on higher education have been dominated by the themes that are being felt most strongly within universities and have come up in every conversation I’ve had this week: fees, Brexit, TEF and widening participation.

After a period of relative quiet in terms of leaks from the post-18 review, fees were back on the agenda this week. It seems that the outcomes of the Augar review are likely to be delayed until at least May due to the political and economic uncertainty surrounding Brexit. While many are keen to know what will come from Augar and remove the uncertainty, there is an argument that we shouldn’t be in too much of a rush to get the results published. It seems as well as Brexit uncertainty, the delay is a consequence of cross- government disagreement on the recommendations. Therefore, delay could lead to a softening of some of the previously rumoured recommendations. It seems this has already happened in some areas, such as the headline reduction shifting from £6,500 to £7,500.

Any delay also gives the sector the opportunity to argue the case for the outcomes which we as want to see. There were a number of examples of this this week, including Martin Lewis partnering with the Russell Group to tackle the issue of ‘misleading’ loan statements and the CBI speaking out about the ‘profound harm’ cuts to tuition fees could cause.

Brexit concerns remain firmly on the higher education agenda and this week’s headlines reflected this. While UK universities had their best performance in the annual QS subject rankings, the league table compilers raised concerns about the impact of leaving the EU on the strength of UK research. The European Temporary Leave to Remain (ETLR) scheme has also been slammed by the Russell Group for failing to take into account four year courses in Scotland and longer courses such as medicine and engineering.

Much focus has also been placed on the Teaching Excellence Framework this week, largely due to the consultation closing on Friday focusing minds. The independent review seems to be encouraging more nuanced discussion of the TEF, with UUK acknowledging that it is having an impact on teaching and learning strategies. However, one of the most startling facts from their report was the overall cost: estimated to be £4 million for those taking part in year two. Does this diverting of resources lead to less money to spend on the teaching it is supposed to be evaluating?

Another questions the review is also going to have to tackle is whether the purpose of the TEF remains suitable.  As David Morris wrote this week, students are largely unaware of the existence of the TEF and aren’t using it in their decision making (although I think it may be too soon to take a view on that). It is clear that there was and remains a desire to make universities more accountable to government in their teaching practices. Perhaps the most useful outcome of the review for universities would be for all parties to acknowledge this as the driver.

The well discussed, but perhaps not yet well tackled issue of widening participation was also catching headlines this week. Shakira Martin, Chris Millward and James Kirkup have all called this week for more radical steps to be taken to address the issues of stalling progress in access to HE.  Francesca Roe called for a focus on breaking down the systematic barriers, rather than misplaced emphasis on aspiration. These messages were echoed by Shakira and Chris as speakers at the HEPI/AdvanceHE House of Commons breakfast seminar this week, which focused on this topic. It is clear that the intentions are good, but more action needs to be taken to make the changes.

It’s still to be seen about whether the trend of headlines reflecting what is going on in HE providers remains beyond this week, but we should certainly welcome the refreshing focus.

Back