Login

close

Login

If you are a registered HEi-know user, please log in to continue.


Unregistered Visitors

You must be a registered HEi-know user to access Briefing Reports, stories and other information and services. Please click on the link below to find out more about HEi-know.

Find out more
HEi News Roundup live

Live higher education news roundup

HEi-think: Reasons to be worried about the future of graduate employment

New figures suggest that more graduates are finding employment or going on to further study. But there are trends within the statistics that raise questions about the direction of the graduate labour market and that could cause concern for the future, warns Stephen Isherwood, Chief Executive of the Association of Graduate Recruiters .

HEi-think: HE needs practical tools to navigate turbulent times

As UK higher education enters a period of unprecedented change and uncertainty, Tony Strike, University Secretary and Director of Strategy at the University of Sheffield, says that more than ever before universities need reliable practical tools to guide them through the challenges they face.

UK universities lose ground in latest QS world rankings

Many UK universities have fallen further behind international competitors in the latest edition of the QS World University Rankings.

“Glacial” progress on closing the gender pay gap, report finds

Closing the higher education gender pay gap will take 40 years, a new report suggests.

HEi-think: White Paper serves up "under-done" teacher training plans

New plans for teacher training contained in the Education White Paper Educational Excellence Everywhere have some merit, but need further development: preferably with the help of the university sector, argues James Noble-Rogers, Executive Director of the Universities’ Council for the Education of Teachers.

 

From a teacher education perspective, the Education White Paper 'Educational Excellence Everywhere' was a bit of an under-done Curate's egg; good in parts but not yet fully boiled. The Universities’ Council for the Education of Teachers (UCET) and the university sector hope to help bring it to the boil over the next few months.

The good news is that at least some ITE providers will receive an allocation of places that will allow them to plan the number of new teachers they will be expected to train to meet the needs of schools in their areas and beyond. That will help avoid some of the catastrophic scenes experienced this year, where a rigged system of recruitment controls led to a rush to recruit, and the perverse spectacle of prospective teachers arriving for interviews only to be turned away at the door. The one concern that we have is whether this stability will apply to all providers, or only to the favoured few.

Replacing QTS with a longer process under which teachers only receive full recognition after a period in the classroom is also a potentially good idea. For it to work, however, new teachers will need access to structured early professional development that builds on and complements their initial training, and which allows time out of school to maintain links with their ITE providers and to reflect alongside their peers. Without this, the new system could in practice turn out to be little changed from the one that we currently have, which would mean another missed opportunity.

There are some very welcome references in the White Paper to the importance of CPD and to research, something that has been overlooked for far too long. We hope that this long overdue recognition will extend to Master's level CPD, which is proven to have a positive impact on both retention and the performance of teachers in the classroom. It may be too much to hope for now, but maybe we will start to move again towards a Master's qualified teaching profession. That really would improve the status of teaching, as well as incentivising high calibre new recruits.

There continues, unfortunately, to be an assumption that 'school-led' training (whatever that actually is) is somehow superior to the more traditional school-university partnerships. There is of course no evidence for this.  All routes into teaching make a valuable contribution and all should be allowed to flourish on an equal footing. That is why it is disappointing that the only new ITE providers that will be accredited are SCITTs, despite the role that university partnerships could fill and despite the fact that universities are, on average, much better at filling places.

Finally, there are the proposals to establish new university centres of excellence. This idea has potential and is very interesting. Although a lot will, as with the rest of the White paper, depend on the detail.

 

toa55 / 123RF
Back