If you are a registered HEi-know user, please log in to continue.
You must be a registered HEi-know user to access Briefing Reports, stories and other information and services. Please click on the link below to find out more about HEi-know.
Live higher education news roundup
New figures suggest that more graduates are finding employment or going on to further study. But there are trends within the statistics that raise questions about the direction of the graduate labour market and that could cause concern for the future, warns Stephen Isherwood, Chief Executive of the Association of Graduate Recruiters .
As UK higher education enters a period of unprecedented change and uncertainty, Tony Strike, University Secretary and Director of Strategy at the University of Sheffield, says that more than ever before universities need reliable practical tools to guide them through the challenges they face.
Many UK universities have fallen further behind international competitors in the latest edition of the QS World University Rankings.
While the number of student complaints appears to have almost plateaued, universities are being challenged by a sharp rise in the proportion that are over the quality and availability of resources, teaching and facilities, and issues relating to a "lad's culture" on campus, warns Rob Behrens, chief executive of the Office of the Independent Adjudicator for higher education, which has published its annual report.
The annual report of the Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education, published today, tells us several things about student complaints and how they are handled.
First, the independent, ‘classic’ ombudsman scheme for students continues to work well as a complaints handler of last resort. OIA decisions are evidence-based, carry authority within the higher education sector, and recommendations are invariably implemented by universities.
Second, most complaints in 2014, as in previous years, were about ‘academic status’, submitted by students who have appealed to their university about a mark or a degree outcome, or being withdrawn from a course. Students on degree courses that lead to a professional qualification, such as law and subjects allied to medicine are more likely than other students to complain. A higher proportion of postgraduates than of undergraduates complain. Unsurprisingly, complaints are statistically more likely when the stakes are highest.
Third, the number of complaints and the overall pattern of outcomes have now been stable for three years. In 2014 we received more cases than ever before (2,040), but the difference over the previous record year is small. We closed 2,175 cases. Almost a quarter of cases (23 per cent) closed in 2014 were Justified or Partly Justified, or the OIA brokered a settlement between the student and the university. That means that, because the student came to the OIA, the university looked at the case again. Additionally, universities paid a total of £400,000 in financial compensation to students for errors, distress and inconvenience.
Fourth, while overall there is little variation between years, a couple of areas stand out. The proportion of complaints about the availability or quality of resources, teaching, supervision and facilities rose to 15 per cent in 2014, from nine per cent in 2013. These cases are in effect about setting and meeting expectations. While the number of complaints remains small, the OIA case-load shows that growing concerns about the ‘lads culture’ and sexual harassment are challenging universities.
Fifth, students and universities do not always help themselves. The annual report lists some of the most common reasons the OIA finds cases Not Justified – students who cannot provide any evidence to support their claims, students who do not take up support offered to them, students who break regulations. It also includes examples of universities making mistakes in the way that they deal with some cases or gaps in procedures.
Sixth, there is a strong commitment to improving the way complaints are handled. The OIA, in partnership with others including the National Union of Students, has published a Good Practice Framework that higher education providers can draw on to develop their procedures for handling complaints and academic appeals.
From this coming September, following the passage of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, higher education students at alternative providers, further education colleges and providers of School-Centred Initial Teacher Training will be able to bring their complaints directly to the OIA. We do not yet know whether these students will complain more or less often, or about the same or different issues than the more than ten thousand students who have used the OIA in the ten years we have been working. What we do know is that, with a wider remit, we will be even better placed to work with the sector to make sure that complaints are properly addressed.
© 2013 Media FHE, all rights reserved